Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
This is about the birds, and the sky is completely white, so I don't see this as meeting the challenge.
Post actions
I really like this photo - from the first thumbnail view!
Post actions
great shot, everyone trys to do this one, and you finally got it. good luck in the challenge!
Post actions
Love this.
Post actions
Typical Phone Call: A couple of "birds" on each end with a bunch of birds in the middle! :}
Post actions
too many birds... to little fancy sky
Post actions
Lovely composition of lines and silhouettes. Lacking in sky but the subject is fully implied. 10.
Post actions
this looks like some really intense Beethoven. 9
Post actions
Post actions
I see this type congregation frequently and you have captured it well. The B&W treatment works nicely for this image.
Post actions
Actually, the sky is obscured by the birds and power lines.
Post actions
Post actions
This image has a great feeling to it. The composition is fantastic.
Post actions
Love the stark contrast..
Post actions
Unfortunately, the sky is the least interesting thing in this photo and considering sky was the main theme of this challenge, I can't vote much higher than a 3.
Post actions
there is actually an absence of sky here. It doesn't quite meet the challenge for me, plus with the expert editing, you could have added a sky to this. 4
Post actions
I see what you are going for, and I like this image as a whole, but when I look at it I don't see sky. I wish maybe there were some details in the background to tell me what I was looking at (although then of course the image would probably look too busy).
Post actions
Post actions
Well-spotted and refreshing.
Post actions
Reminds me of a Counting Crows album art. I like.
Post actions
Post actions
The sky in this case is flat white. Not exactly interesting as a sky shot per se.
Post actions
Simple, stark, and very engaging. Nice work!
Post actions
HEE HEE - love all the birds. NICE use of high contrast!
Post actions
Great B&W here. This one needs to go in one of those black and white coffee table books. Well done. The sky thing is a stretch. Not much of a sky, but it certainly is a sky, so no points docked. Well done!
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
