Author Thread
Post actions
Wow Tate! This is deep! Another superb image from your creative brain. I love this and think it should have ribboned. Congratulations in the top 5!
Post actions
I really liked this one. Congrats on the top 5 finish. Go TEAM!
Post actions
Awesome photo! Executed to perfection. . .and I think the lighting is great. See? If you'd have said you did it in your professional home studio, no one would ever know with a 6.8 score and a 4th place finish :)
Post actions
I thought this would ribbon Tate...you just missed out...Manny beat you, but this is equally great...well done on 4th
Post actions
So this was yours :) I'm pleased to see that, as it was one of the pictures I scored the highest. Like it a lot...
Post actions
Nice shot, congrats on your top5-finish!
Post actions
Neat shot! Congrats on HM.
Post actions
Tate. You do yourself proud, and the Team as well. I voted this high, and wondered how on earth it was done. Super, and a very,very nice finish.
Post actions
Lovely surreal rendition. Congratulations on your 4th place.
Post actions
This is a really fun, creative shot. Well done!
Post actions
Your "stupid" lighting didn't keep this idea from getting an honorable mention. Congrats.
Post actions
Congrats on top 5! Very amusing juxtaposition of concept, title, and image.
Post actions
Excellent work Tate. Congrats on 4th!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
this is an excellent, sharp, graphic and interesting shot ..... great composition too!!
Post actions
amazing ... albert
Post actions
Nicely done. Clarity, composition and lighting are all good.
Post actions
Post actions
Lovely combination of elements, title and surrealism. Love it.
Post actions
Post actions
It's too pretty for a dirt pic....Love it...I didn't know thing was a gardener.
Post actions
Neat conept! Something seems a little off to me technically... blue glow around the can and plant?
Post actions
This is a really cool picture. I wanted to do something with a hand like this, but this is much, much better than what I even had in my mind.
Post actions
great concept and title, things do grow from the earth's-dirt. more emphasis on oodles of Brown-dirt, but I like the sharpness and composition. -
Post actions
Hmmm... the scalvert approach... nice!!! - 6
Post actions
Post actions
very clever. Good luck with this one and i expect it to be front page at rollover.
Post actions
Post actions
DPC Dirt. nice clean hand, nice clean background. a bit of zen. I actually like this one out of the "clean" shots, but I'm saving my highest scores for true grime. 7
Post actions
Very clever.....very very clever indeed...
Post actions
Post actions
Hmmmm. This is a funny picture. Such a clean hand coming out of the dirt, and the water is not running off the leaf. Very curious. ~7
Post actions
Very well done. Great composition.
Post actions
Great concept and well executed!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Oh, I don't know why yet, but I love this. 10
Post actions
Very clever. I think I know who did this too. (;~p) 9
Post actions
I like this shot, the only problem I see is the back of the thumb is a little too dark. If it had been an inch or so back further it would have evened the shadow out more.
Post actions
very creative, excellent set up!
Post actions
Incredibly creative. Well done.
Post actions
this should ribbon...good luck...well executed and a creative idea 10
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
