Author Thread
Post actions
Thanks to all for the usefuls comments!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Cool concept. Background of a wood floor? Little extra effort with a black background (or some solid color) and this would look about 10 times better.
Post actions
This is beautiful, did you know the actual color of this leaf is yellow. Very Creative Idea.
Post actions
beautifully set up, well done
Post actions
Absolutely amazing. What a fantastic idea and execution too.
Post actions
Interesting concept, probably better executed on earth rather than on a floor.
Post actions
I love the idea, just wish you'd chosen a different background. Good luck anyway.
Post actions
very creative...I like the idea....perhaps the background could have been different, but on second thoughts, I think it's appropriate...well done 8
Post actions
Post actions
simple idea, beautifully done
Post actions
very good I love the way you have put the leaf at different stages up to death but I would have prefered a more distracting background
Post actions
I like the idea; a different background (on soil, for example) would be better.
Post actions
Nice perspective...could have been shot better with the older ones fading out ... but great perspective...couldnt have struck me
Post actions
I like the idea. But the presentation is not very impressive. A closer crop would have worked better (maybe less leaves to allow for it). I think the lighting is a little off took, as it adds all these white highlights to the leaves, instead of just letting us see the colours. So, to resume: great idea, but to improve, you could use less leaves (maybe 5), separate them and zoom in closer, fix lighting.
Post actions
It would have been perfect if ths had a plain white background, still I think is a veri nice graphical idea. At least someone did something different with leafs.
Post actions
Well thought out piece. "if it was mine" I'd probably crop out a lot of the background adding more emphasis on the leaves. But it's not, it's yours, and I really like the idea behind this very nice image.
Post actions
great lineup... especially since they are spread across the remains of a tree...
Post actions
Not the best photo in the challenge but certainly worth something. Great idea...8
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Nice idea and I like the lighting and the tones and textures. Not sure about the centered composition but otherwise, I like it. 7
Post actions
Post actions
I really love the idea of this but I think the wood floor boards hurt it. If placed on a solid white or black background, it would have worked better.
Post actions
interesting...
Post actions
Post actions
very cool setup of the leaves from fresh to dried up and dead...
Post actions
I would love this on a solid black or white background. The wood grain, despite the tree connection, is distracting IMO.
Post actions
It would be nice if this was cropped down just to the leaves. The space outside is more of a distraction than anything
Post actions
Nice idea: but an extreme tight crop on this would perhaps have been more dramatic
Post actions
What you did with the leaves is very nice. I really like it. I wish it was on a different background though. Maybe a white background would help the leaves pop.
Post actions
nice idea, creative execution.
Post actions
Very nice idea!
Post actions
I wish the background was white!
Post actions
Picture that tell a story without words. Nice!
Post actions
neat idea, the floor is distracting. I different background would make this a really strong image.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
