I like the selective desat in this photo, as it has a reason. Not sure how you pulled it off in basic, but the photo was validated, so you obviously did. 6.
Great effect with the grey and green. Good title, but the photo itself doesn't jump out at you - if you know what I mean. Like someone said about my entry: it lacks that WOW power. Good luck
Nice idea. I think that the selective desat works ok here. Mayeb a bit of color left in the leaves and twigs could have left a better feel tyo the image overall. Still a 7 from me.