Long title - cool shot. Crikkie (Sp?) love the reflection, it took me awhile to see the other one. I think this is a wonderful shot -what do these voters know I think you should have been the top 40.
I think you should resize this to the largest (640) pixel size (width) that is legal. At 572 pixels the viewer is missing out on some of the available detail. Also, the composition might be helped with a "rule of thirds" crop or by shooting at a lower angle. -6
I think getting a little close in to the subject would have made for much better shot... lol jk. Love the reflection! I think cropping a little tighter on the left would have been nice to balance the subject more. 5
Meets the challenge well, but a rather uninspired composition. Getting right down at water level might've put the reeds in the skyline, or had a reflection of the landscape. (Or got your foot bitten off, of course...)