A simple image can always be one of the more powerful. I like the use of negative space. The candle makes the red glow nicely. Definitely fits the challenge, I just wish the focus wasn't so soft. The softness does work in the image, but I think it could still use a little sharpening. Overall a very nice photo. 6
Not a terrible idea, but this isn't the most interesting picture. You have captured the audience eye right away by the use of negative space, but the small interest detail doesn't hold it. I think a harder focus of the candle with some additional soft elements in the image would help it a lot.
Good Points: I see your idea, good one.
Bad points: too much negative space, and the subject is out of focus. I tried something the same in the life challenge and got ranked badly ;(
Overall Score:2