I think this is a beautiful image, the composition is great, the image fresh and crisp. The bright color of the star does separate it a bit from the image, but the fact that there are other pieces in it makes it seem less alone than it could. Still a great photo! 8
I really like the background. Very nicely done the way the texture fades away to appear to be slick at the top. Nice use of the shadow. The lighting adds 2 more points to it. Great job - nice 9
Simple and great! I like the background's softness against the sharp edges of the... whatever it is, for me it seems like an opened egg shaped object. 9 or 10? Mmm... Sun is shining, I give you 10 (but no way worst than 9).
That's pretty cool but I'm a little thrown off by the almost complete whiteness around the candles. I just barely make out the rest of the table or cloth these are resting on and I'd prefer to see more of it. 7
Unique idea and shot...I really like the white on white and the shadow...this one also would have been great in the shadow challenge. Hope to see this one near the top! I give it a 10!
love the texture and the color.. somehow this photo isn't compelling enough to me. maybe my simple mind is below critiquing this photo accurately.. a 6 from me.