7. Glasses need to be crisper in focus, especially the rims and bases. I like the shadows cast on the chair and the fact that the label is turned toward the the camera.
I like the use of the window light and I like the composition. I also like that it is in black and white. As far as I am concerned it is a good picture.
Catching the reflections on glass is hard, and you did a really nice job. The window makes a nice background, but the view through it is very distracting.
Beautiful lighting in your composition. I like how the foreground with the bottle and the glasses is really dark and the background where the shadows are cast is really lit and bright. Great contrasting. The window and the brightness helps to bring the wine bottle and glasses out of the picture.
An arresting photo. I like the b&w choice. I like the rigid lines of the window panes playing background to the more organic curves of the bottle and glasses. I do find the smidges of glare a little distracting but overly much. What actual grabs my attention negatively is the window looks streaked. Weird huh?? Also, this is just curiousity - is that bottle bent at the top or is that just perspective and lighting playing tricks on me? The filled glass has good focus, but I wish the other one and the bottle wasn't quite as soft focused. Great framing and overall presentation. 7