Gorgeous color, vivid just how I like it. I like the offcenter positioning. The very round aspect of the pumpkin draws my eyes in and keeps it there for the most part. Black background really makes the color shine, excellent use of light. My only distraction is that line of..glare? reflection? in the bottom left. Very solid image. 8
I like the colour of the pumpkin, and the black background. IMHO the border doesn't work well with the picture :) The top right and bottom left corners also could be cropped, maybe the picture could be a rectangle (1/3 background, 2/3 pumpkin)? Something to try. Gave it a 4
Oh my gosh this is a gorgeous shot, caught my eye, the lighting is wonderful! I like the way you just put the soft glow on one side of the pumpkin and chose not to show the whole pumpkin was a good choice. Question what is in the lower left corner...I am nosey..ha ha...great job!9
Very nice
What is that distraction in the lower left corner?
Just a little to much glare on the pumpkin.
I don't like the frame it is tacky looking.
Frames are hard to go with in the challenges.