Awwww... so cute. I like the tones in this one. I like the contrast of the dark hands against the light-toned chick. After reading your photographer's comments, I like the shot even more. I'd say this is under rated. Sorry to see it scored below 5.
I like the framing and composition of this shot but it is out of focus and there is motion blur arround the chicks head, a faster shutter speed woulld reduce motion blur and a higher appiture setting would give greater depht of focus