No flour? No Milk? If it really is that easy I'll be making them! : This is a very good shot overall, the cropping, the set up is welld one. The lighting seems to come from a natural source but the egg seems so dark and lost. I had started at a 7 but am bumping up to an 8
It meets the challenge, and technically is fine, however it could be presented in a more attractive way. Eg: a nice plate instead of plastic, and perhaps having the indgredients measured out instead of in their commercial containers. Just my preference of course.
Cookies look delicious! I like the range of color, and the lighting. I find myself wishing the bottom part of the pyrex was in focus more, but only because everything else in the photo seems to have a nice clear look. That's my only real complaint. I like how the photo comes together. 8
I made some of these cookies this evening too! Wonderfully easy recipe. The color of the cookies is good, although the light on them seems a little uneven with more on the front than the back, which also makes the peanut butter container a little in the shadow too. Compositionally it doesnt really feel that balanced, perhaps it is the jug that's throwing it off some. The angle on the cookies is good, although it looks a little off on the containers.