I think the lighting is really fantastic; despite the high contrast, there's detail in the shadows, which is pretty impressive. I don't think people really know what they're looking at, so I hope you don't let the score discourage you. That picture is so great.
Just look at those beautiful lines of sunlight, the profound mystery of his hidden face, resonating with the mystery of the background. Utter darkness in his shadows, utter darkness in the background and foreground... while the subject lies in the light that exists between the two. It is as if we are looking at his sleep, rather than him. I'll start this at 9.