Nice to see some good use of the reflective surface here as some of the other of these shots blatently dont when it is such a useful thing. I understand it is hard to shoot one of these but perhaps there is a little too much red in it, Pulling out the backdrop just slightly would imho have been nice to see. Still a very good and promising image
Good Points:like the way it's lit, very different, and good focus on the cylinder part
Bad Points:a bit unoriginal, seen about 10 of thse allready.
Score:6
This is a very busy shot, the red lights are very distracting to me. The clarity of circle on the right helps make up for that. This almost looks like it was taken through a peice of glass but I do like the lines of light on the left. I'm starting a little lower on this one since it doesn't intially appeal to me but I'll be back and I'm sure the score will go up as I study it more. Start with a 5