Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
You are a brave person indeed...I like it...I like it a lot.
Post actions
Could you at least pretend to follow the rules and crop the image correctly? :-)
Post actions
Nice idea. I love this image. I hope you place!
Post actions
I'm confused, but in a good way. I like this, I like it alot. It certainly lives up to its title. Not sure if it will be accepted as a Portrait by all members, but who cares! Its a wonderful image that keeps you looking; looking out into the landscape beyond. Hope it does well.
Post actions
10..we had the same idea, but i never came up with THIS idea so i went with (secret, cant tell you)...NICE JOB!
Post actions
great shot well done, would have liked a slightly larger view but still a 7
Post actions
It's clever, and I think it works; but your depth of field doesn't seem to quite extend to infinity, and that hurts your shot.
Post actions
Post actions
interesting concept. I think you could exploit this idea even further by not having the subject so centered in the image.
Post actions
Post actions
awesome picture, superb lighting, not in portrait orientation though
Post actions
I really love this image...perhaps in a frame challenge this would ribbon...I reckon the voters are giving you a hard time by now...I like it 8
Post actions
You've just got to enter both of them, Don't you? More power to ya! I would have done the same thing, if I had thought of it first! :)
Post actions
I love this one so much, I want to hug it, and stroke it, and name it George. (10)
Post actions
Well performed, I like how you make the colors stand out and how the forground is darker than the rest...
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
You'll drive the DNMC folks crazy with this one. Does it meet? Yes it does, no it doesn't, maybe it does, I give up. LOL - Nice shot is what I say!
Post actions
WOW - now that's a twist. I like it but I wonder if the "literal" police will kill you on this. So nice to see originality. Great image. I like the symmetry. 8
Post actions
Post actions
This would very cool with a square crop similar to the windows!
Post actions
creative interpretation of challenge. I'll give extra bonus points for that!
Post actions
err, "landscape in portrait orientation" means, that the width of the photo is smaller than its height; this is "landscape in landscape orientation". Still, it is a nice idea well executed.
Post actions
Got to love this one. Great DOF. Awesome find.
Post actions
Great picture but not portrait.
Post actions
I really like this shot very much. It's a shame the orientation's not correct for the challenge.
Post actions
I love this image, but am taking a couple of points off because the orientation of the whole shot is landscape (DNMC).
Post actions
Post actions
I like the photo, but I can't see how this fits the challenge description.
Post actions
interesting interpretation of the challenge. Well seen.
Post actions
This is a brilliant shot and very well exposed. You should have saved it for the free study though as nothing here really looks portrait. Oh, the windows could be slightly portrait, but they feel more square than anything.
Post actions
Very clever take on the challenge. I hope you do not suffer too many DNMC-type thinkers.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting idea. You might get some DNMCs, but I actually really like it.
Post actions
oh, ok, thanks for the title, coz i was wondering:).. actually, this is great! i like what u did with the light most of all!
Post actions
Clever, got me on that one.
Post actions
So where's the landscape orientation?
Post actions
3D photography, well done and presented.
Post actions
Like the way you have done landscape in portrait twice, cropping this would have lost the impact - excellent shot
Post actions
Post actions
Sneaky, sneaky! Really interesting shot. I'll buy it but I dunno how others are gunna feel!
Post actions
Excellent idea and execution. Now, why didn't you just have it as a portrait, as per challenge requirements? I hate it but I'll have to deduct...
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
