YUM!! Walnuts! Okay, not really, not my favorite nut but you made them look good! I like the cropping on this shot and the concept overall. The lighting does bother me though, too much yellow, a little bit brighter and I would start this one a little higher. I'm starting with a 7 but I will be back.
Good subject. Focus is good in the mid and background. The lighting seems like it was taken indoors under flourescent lamps and maybe doesn't do the walnuts justice.
I think you have a strong subject choice here, but the overall composition seems to be a bit lacking. The tonal range seems a bit flat and the yellow tint could be contributing to that.
Good Points: idea and comp are good single nut amongst others brings it out more.
Bad Points:way too much yellow, try removing in ps. a few more nuts would be good at teh foot of the photo
Score:6