Author Thread
Post actions
Lovely picture. Congrats on your top 20 finish!
Post actions
I gave this a 10 and was surprised to see it finish outside the top ten! Your conversion to BW is exceptional, and the sharpness of details is great. The foreground image is interesting, and the skyline behind it adds an unexpected element. I think this shot is superb!
Post actions
Oh Charmayne!!! This is absolutely stunning! How this photo didn't ribbon or end up with a 7.0 score is beyond me! Wow! You did a fantastic job on this excellent photo! It is flawless!
Post actions
Charmayne: what a hefty and lovely urban image. Congratulations on your top 20 finish.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I love the metallic silvery tones in this image, bump.
Post actions
Sweet shot - kind of dreamy - love it!!
Post actions
great image, love the color and tone, so icy and cold. wonderful.
Post actions
Wonderful! Love the crispness of it all.
Post actions
Like this shot a lot. The curving train with the building in the background-perfect!!
Post actions
wow nice shot, crisp clean image, sharp shooting 9
Post actions
beautiful crisp clear shot with fantastic processing. good luck in the challenge.
Post actions
The lighter shades works to make me feel cold. Very nice.
Post actions
Nicely done. I think that is the F train at Smith and 9 in/near Redhook, is it not? The b/w treatment is great. I can't fault your photo. 10.
Post actions
Meets Challenge - 2
Post actions
Interesting, I love the metallic look and the skyline in the background!
Post actions
Post actions
nice combination of train and skyline...
Post actions
-9-great clarity and tones.composition is outstanding.
Post actions
Beautiful conposition!!! This should be a postcard for sure.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
