This is a well thought out composition and an excellent photograph. The subtle tones are showing nice detail in the shadows without blowing the highlights. The bright orange vest completely balances the dark shadows on the left and the splash of color in the reflection is superb. High marks for one of my favorites in this challenge.
I like the train & the smile on the conductor. I like the angle of the train and the resulting lines. I find myself wishing the man in the orange were not in the shot. Great challenge entry.
Good shot here. Very sound composition. Nice tonality in the image. It is very easy to come across as 'gimmicky' when doing selective desat. But I think here, it serves a good purpose, and helps drive the photo's idea, and it 'works'. Nice job.