well, this is mostly what i see in the morning while driving the highway into the citiy for work :-)
exif:
Model Canon EOS 350D DIGITAL
Date/time original 12.10.2006 8:12:49
Shutter speed value 1/640 s
Aperture value f/4
ISO speed ratings ISO 200
Exposure bias value 0.00 eV
Metering mode Pattern
Flash Flash did not fire, compulsory flash mode
Focal length 70 mm
White balance Auto white balance
First, let me thank you for including so many details in your photographer's comments. Now for the critique. My first impression is that this definitely looks like morning fog and has an interesting subject. With nearly one third of your votes being a 5 and over half the votes in the 5 to 6 range, to me that indicates that the voters looked for literally 2-3 seconds and concluded, "this picture isn't bad, so I can't give 4 or less, but it doesn't have a lot of wow, so I can't give it a 7 or higher". For some reason, black and white images didn't score very well in this challenge. I also see by the comments left during voting that the large amount of negative space above the trees was a love it or hate type thing. It would have been safer to crop tighter on the trees, maybe in a landscape format, but the image might have lost some of its impact. Personally I like the portrait format and wouldn't change a thing. You have a very good image that anyone at DPC would be proud to have in their portfolio.
Feel free to PM me if you have any questions regarding this critique.
Too much negative space. if the contrast was a bit more stark rather than graduated from the fog, then the extra negative space may have been more effective. With those elements I would have cropped down just a bit and it would have been more effective.
Ooooooh. . .I love photos like this! I love the fog, and I love the minimalist approach to this type of scene. Fantastic photo! I really hope its doing well!