I have just looked at your Urban challenge photo.a 4.1 with all the comments of don't meet challenge, Just think if they thought it met the challenge what your score might have been, That all adds up to one thing It's a great photo.
Sue
It's a pretty coast, but...I odn't see any sign of a city, town, or even a small cluster of outbuildings. Is there a city out in the fog, or just behind? In any case...I can't tie this to the challenge at all.
yes, actually there is. Just to the left below the mountains.
It's a pretty coast, but...I odn't see any sign of a city, town, or even a small cluster of outbuildings. Is there a city out in the fog, or just behind? In any case...I can't tie this to the challenge at all.
With only the rocks to represent buildings this is pushing the envelope to meet the challenge for me. On the shot itself, if any of it has a sharper focus, either the front or the background I would go much higher on the overall shot. It looks like a lovely area, the mist rolling in is very inviting to me.
I love this photo. It is well composed and has a wonderful mood. You missed an opportunity to have fun. If there had even been a washed away sand castle in the frame, I would have voted higher. Sorry, there is no way to stretch this to the meet the challenge.
Pretty picture, but I'm not sure where the focus is. And two small things: 1) I wish the middle reed didn't reach into the water, and 2) there's nothing "urban" here to meet the challenge.
Almost looks like haystack in Astoria. Well, can't really rate this too high - it's a great shot, but no buildings (at least that I see). It aslo isn't very 'urban'. But it is a nice shot, nonetheless.
Even though I don't believe this meets the challenge, and your focus is too soft in the foreground, I am a sucker for mist images and this one has a great sci-fi feel to it. Almost appears to be a distant planet's landscape. 6 Would have been higher had it met the challenge.
This interpretation, I suspect, will get some flak here for stretching the topic. It is, however, quite a beautiful capture, which I'm rating accordingly. Would a slight change of perspective have resulted in a more pleasing composition with respect to the centred rock or mount? The single grass stem appears just a little too sparse to achieve a fully balanced result.
I also wish the image was a little larger than it is.
This isn't an urban landscape, it is a landscape. Urban means in the city or town, so in an urban landscape you gotta see bridges, buildings that kind of stuff.
While I like this picture very much I do not think it represents "Urban Landscapes." Urban to me is inner city while this is rural, seaside, or country. It does not portray Urban.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
