I really like your idea and composition. The tarp has a strange color quality to it and I wish something (probably the water) was really in sharp focus. However, I can see where you were going with this and with a different camera I think this would do really well. Good eye for creating an interesting shot.
I don't think this is going to score to well. It isn't in focus anywhere, it's grainy, and the colors seem to be washed out. The composition is kind of fun, except for the two trees that flank the water runoff.
Not sure what is in focus here, if anything. There is also a lot of noise in the image. I think if these things are improved it would be a much better image.
Hmm, focus is lacking and the all around of the quality of the image (as in the image and not the photography) isn't great. Although the composition in interesting. Good use of colours, division of frame with the water, blue and trees.
Very good photo - we always without fail camp in rain (for ten years of trips). I can relate to this in ways you would never predict. 8 for comradeship. Just wish you had better clarity. But then again, in such conditions, what are you gonna do!? ;-) 7.