We finally got some rain here. I was a little worried I would not be able to get a rain picture. This is the first setup shot that I have done. I love the look of the rain on our front window and my wife had some candles in the window so I set up the shot and I really like the way it turned out.
Post processing:
adjusted white balance, levels and USM
Statistics
Place: 87 out of 128 Avg (all users): 5.0685 Avg (commenters): 6.3333 Avg (participants): 5.0377 Avg (non-participants): 5.0742 Views since voting: 1016 Views during voting: 472 Votes: 336 Comments: 14 Favorites: 0
The focus might have been better placed on the candle holders even though the window is showing the rain for the challenge. I think the voters would have been able to see that even if it wasn't in focus.
It looks like the right holder is more in focus but a lot of people read from left to right and that carries over to photos. By seeing the left holder first, one assumes the right one isn't in focus either, especially in a symetrical composition. The voters will spend about 3 seconds looking at the picture and will naturally jump to conclusions.
A different take on the challenge. Its not quite grabbing me though. The focus is a bit soft on the right candle stick and the composition just isn't interesting enough to draw me in.
I like the idea of this, rather than your execution - I'm not sure how you might make it more impactful, but a couple of things stand out for me immediately: your depth of field is very shallow, such that the candles are not particularly in focus, along with the rainy window. Also there's a lack of a feel of contrast - you've exposed well enough for the light of the candles themselves, but the light beyond that is rather flat and uninteresting - perhaps simply waiting until the day outside were a little darker might have done it.