Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Unfortunately this doesn't look real enough for me. The water is very white while the milk has a yellowish tint to it. The glass of milk isn't blending in with the picture very well because of that color difference and because of the overall texture of the image - the photo isn't as clear as the glass of milk and the photo is grainy.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Great shot...will be curious to see how this one was done when the voting is over!
Post actions
neat idea, and a very good job of hiding the cut's in the waterfall picture. almost perfect
Post actions
Good color, I like the waterfall.
Post actions
some good thought went into this picture. nicely done.
Post actions
Post actions
hmmm don't know how you did this legally. Its interesting.
Post actions
Great visual, not sure I see how it meets the challenge, water vs. milk? Watered down milk, am I being too literal?
Post actions
I wish the photo was as clear as the the glass of milk... would be alot more believable then. Nice idea tho...
Post actions
Very clever idea and nicely done, but more of an illusion than Irony.
Post actions
Post actions
base 1: 1/1; challenge: 1/3; technical: 2/3; aesthetics: 1/3; total: 5
Post actions
cool shot! How you do it?
Post actions
Post actions
might be a good subject for a "How'd they do that?" forum thread
Post actions
Maybe if the levels had been adjusted to make the milk/ice all the same color. Here we have creamy white milk and white ice.. I do applaud your creative thinking, not a bad attempt.
Post actions
clever creation. I assume you cut a waterfall photo to have it flowing into the milk? I don't see the irony in the shot but I like your creativity.
Post actions
Interesting ad - no irony
Post actions
Post actions
This is really great. It's humorous, but not really ironic. Still one of the best shots I've seen so far.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
