Fits The Challenge - Ummm sure, but the motive is not very intresting.
Composition - I would say you need to check out things like rule of thirds and stuff just to get your composition running.
Background - Blue? Not very intresting.
Digital Processing - Is there actually any?
My Opinion - I am not impressed with this image and I will not even take the border into my considiration. People have different views about borders and I think neither for or against them.
Well to the image, The subject is not very intresting, its from a very simple angle and I think that this sure could have been a good photo with some angle work and then some cool B&W conversion or something.
Well I don't know how much more I can say about this.
I hope you don't take this personaly becouse I think people should get harsh critique when they don't do a good enough job.
I really like this composition, but not sure if the frame works well (I should refrain from commenting on that :) as I am not good at chosing frames myself) Good shot, I hope it does well.
Great idea, I would have been tempted to crop all of the lamp on the right handside out of the shot as I think its a little distracting. I do like the light on the post against the colour of the sky :o)