Critique Club Review:
The lighting is so harsh and dramatic, it takes a moment to figure this one out. It is almost as if the eyes have to adjust to the lighting.
The large amount of negative space and sharp contrasts, add to the drama. I have to agree that the title doesn't fit the picture. Forgotten doesn't come to mind. But, then again I try not to vote titles. Can't say the same holds true for all. I do factor meeting the challenge into my vote, but you've certainly done that here.
I agree with you, a fog would have really added to this piece. The tree is alone, and looks a little forlorn physically. But the lighting says center stage, star of the show. So there is a bit of presentation tension.
Overall, a very interesting photo and one I could see hanging in a gallery. Nice job. |