Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Great photo, but I don't think it meets the challenge./..
Post actions
This is a lovely shot. The reflection has great clarity, and the brightness of the water really stands out, drawing the eye. However, i'm not seeing a strong connection to the challenge topic.
Post actions
Love the luminescent quality of this pi. Whether it is a silhouette...... I like it tho'
Post actions
this is nothing close to being a silhouette? I am also thinking that this is selective color in a basic editing challenge? Great shot wrong challenge
Post actions
I like this shot, but I do not think it exactly meets the challenge
Post actions
That's a really cool picture, but no silhouette?
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Nice photo but I don't really think it is fit for the challenge
Post actions
Too much detail to be a silhouette. Won't go any lower than 5 though, cause it's a really nice photo. 5.
Post actions
Great image. Not really what I think of as a silhouette.
Post actions
Post actions
this is a wonderful shot, but its not a silhouette
Post actions
Nicely composed, but too much light and detail to be considered a silhouette.
Post actions
This is a gorgeous image but I see more shadow than silhouette, and I don't think they're the same thing. In a different challenge I'd give it a 9.
Post actions
The translucencies of this silhouette make it different from the rest. The composition is excellent as are all the technicals. Excellent photo!
Post actions
I really like the colors, crop and reflection. To me, it's just barely a silhouette but I like it.
Post actions
doesn't meet challenge.... there's not really a silhouette in there...
Post actions
Ahhh this is very nice although Im not quite sure people would class it as a silhouette
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
