really like the soft glow on this...seems that score should have been much better, but then there were 678 entries...so that makes it tougher...your % placement is pretty good...very sweet picture
didn't see this in the challenge - but just love it.
How do you get that softness in there? is that a Glam Glow action? It sure is cool.
This is art that is worthy to hang on many walls! Really has a timeless, every person's memory kind of feel to it. I related to it instantly - ah the magic of photography.
This is very nice work - you should be proud to have a shot like this in your portfolio.
Technical: contrast is great for this image, the black and white adds alot...
Creativity: you have great creativity here...such a simple yet powerful image
Personal Opinion: i absolutely love the soft hue to this image, her stance, the expression (or lack of) it's all great!
Score: 10
appropriate softness for scene. Like the tones used. You would think the dark clump at the bottom right would be distracting but it actually (for me anyway) balances the image. Well done and well cropped.
Composition: 7 - Really nice, not quite centered but not quite following the generic "rules" - works well!
Technical: 6 - I like the soft focus and the high key but its a shame the hat blends into the sky.
Creativity: 6 - I like that it poses questions such as where is she going, and what is she looking at?
Appeal: 6 - Could add appeal by adding a slight sepia tint, really subtly, just to add some warmth. The B&W just seems a bit cold and uninteresting.