The lighthouse in the Hudson River is picturesque, but as I was taking photographs of it I saw the sailboat upriver. I waited about 15 minutes for it to reach the lighthouse.
Adjusted curves, cropped, cloned out a few gaps in the trees and applied USM.
Statistics
Place: 639 out of 684 Avg (all users): 4.5280 Avg (commenters): 4.2857 Avg (participants): 4.4822 Avg (non-participants): 4.6981 Views since voting: 1097 Views during voting: 320 Votes: 250 Comments: 15 Favorites: 0
The sailboat really adds to this shot as does the green floating life in the foreground. Overall seems to be lacking sharpness and may be due to it be a small section of a much larger image?
The picture does not look sharp on my monitor and the colours look a bit off. I also think getting in closer would make for a better picture. The house is placed fine for the composition, but there isn't anything to draw the eye to it. As it is the lighthouse and the boat competes for attention.
Composition: 3 - Its very centered and uninteresting to me, but you did follow near the rule of thirds with the horizon placement.
Technical: 2 - The whites are overexposed and there are halos around things from poor sharpening. If you used USM, try using a smaller radius, 0.3 or 0.4 for this sized photo.
Creativity: 3 - This straight on shot could be improved by experimenting with more dramatic angles.
Appeal: 1 - Sorry, this doesnt hold my interest at all, with its dull colours, poor processing, and uninteresting subjects.
a nice image, but the poor resolution quality will bring your score down. you either need to raise the resolution in your camera, or save differently for hte web.