Haha, like the humor here :) Think the shot is a bit flat, for my tastes anyway and I would have voted higher if it were brighter and more contrast. 6 from me.
Cute. The still water is great in contrast with the little gater guy. I think if this was just a smidge closer and the subject was placed mosr toward the upper corner it might have been more effective.
Like the choice of B&W and it is good use of the rule of thirds.
After being stranded in the desert the water here looks a lot more inviting than the gator looks scary to me. :) - Steve
Eeeeee. . .you are BAAAAAAAAAAAD!! Very creative idea tho! And I do love the minimalist look of this photo. I must be bad too because this really made me smile :) There's just a little bit too much noise for a 10, but gotta give it a 9!