Beautifully done. Being a parent is certainly is full of magic & mystery and you captured it well in this pic (right down to the little bit of drool! hee hee). The love the father has is tangible here. There is a very light odd circle on the fathers forehead - not sure if that's a lighting issue but I'm still bumping you to an 8 for a job well done. Oh - and B&W is perfect here.
I originally gave this a 5 because the image didn't convey magic or mystery to me, but it's a nice shot nonetheless. And I usually expect the picture to tell the story, with the title as icing on the cake. However, here the title got me to broaden my perspective (esp. since I have two young daughters!).
Now, looking at the photo itself, I like the lighting, how you placed the baby and the dad's face, and of course the baby's expression! B&W works nicely, too.