The lighting is very intersting and her character is great, but I almost wish her elbow wasn't there. I wish that the geico was maybe on her chest or head... or something, but again, the lighting is great.
A newt? "...I got better, but she's a witch! burn her anyway!" I bet your model hates the lighting accentuating the bags under her eyes, but it helps make the shot. If I get to nitpick, I'd like something other than a tank or t shirt, a robe maybe with the sleeves pulled up for a more drapy effect? Great shot.
This image meets the challenge, because I can see it's somehow about magic, so I start with a 5. Her expression is funny, but a little blurry, and I don't really understand how the orange ball relates to her expression or the newt. I tend to prefer titles that are icing on the cake and have the image tell the story, and even with the title, it's missing something for me. I do like the composition - her face, the ball, and the newt are in good positions. 5.