The only 'bad' thing about this shot is the blown out area at the top, and even that doesn't bother me too much. Love the DoF, focus is on the right spot, and the speedo becomes a less distracting part of the background. An excellent photograph.
This shot must not have wide enough appeal. It was in my top ten, and I think it's awesome. Technically one of the best in the challenge. My bf wasn't too crazy about it though, and it obviously didn't score as high as it should have. I love it. The blue, the dof, the composition. It's great! Definitely can't judge the merits of a photo based on dpc score.
I remember this view from over my uncle's shoulder. If the depth of field were deeper, I think it would be an even better shot, at least in my opinion.