Author Thread
Post actions
Jason, thans for your comment on my photo for on the beach challenge, I thought i would give the comment back, and I agree with your comment that I could have moved over to get that light out of the way, I am not sure how much I noticed when I shot the photo. I think this shot is great, it was one of only three 9's I gave out in the whole challenge. The way you processed this image is excellent. My one complaint would be this border that you used, I think using no border or something much smaller would have helped your score go up a few tenths higher. Thanks again for your comment and this is an excellent image,
Post actions
gorgeous beautiful shot. I'm sorry I didn't vote in this challenge!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Great job, and although I love the intesity of the 'color' in this one, I just don't get the water part, it's too hard to tell it's really water, and hints that it's fog. It's not enough of either one to be able to tell. I gave this a 5.
Post actions
framing is distracting, nice image though
Post actions
Very nice shot and post processing. Nice emotional surreal feel. The beveled border is a bit distracting but still a good overall shot.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Awesome photo. I love the composition but you could had got more of the log. I like the textures in it and it would maybe more interesting.
Post actions
I really like this shot, one of the few black and white beach shots that actually looks great. The picture just takes your eye throughout the entire picture. Nice job.
Post actions
Great shot. Border really takes away from pic.
Post actions
Nice shot that is overpowered by the frame.
Post actions
3-D-framing of this otherwise beautiful image is a deadly sin; should be as simple and calm as the image itself. - 6
Post actions
Nice image, but I don't like the heavy border !
Post actions
Very nice shot. Th eframe may be a bit much but the capture inside is very nice and the black and white works well. Good job.
Post actions
Love the photo but i will have to call the border police.
Post actions
I am sure other comments say this as well but; it is a beautiful photo ruined by a very distracting border. The eye wants to look at the rounded border edges instead. Take the border away and this may have scored quite high. Since I am a border guy though I wish you the best of luck!
Post actions
fun photo, think the log could use a little move to the left and i dont like the frame at all, it takes away from a great photo.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Very nice, perhaps a simpler border though.
Post actions
Nice picture without the frame. IMHO
Post actions
I found the boarder quite distracting. I think plain black without the beveled edges would have been nicer, but the photo itself is very very nice.
Post actions
I like the view down the tree trunk. I would suggest a thinner border, it kind of overwhelms the photograph
Post actions
Lovely shot, very subdued and tranquil. Great contrast, solid composition, and the border really adds to it. 10
Post actions
I'm not too sure about that border.
Post actions
I think this would have been nicer without the border, lovely perspective.
Post actions
Nice Black and White and good composition.
Post actions
Post actions
Th border completely destroys this otherwise fine shot. 5.
Post actions
I like the picture a lot, but the frame is a bit large in my opinion. I still feel this is one of the more interesting photos in this challenge. 9
Post actions
I love the picture but I don't think the frame is doing anything for it.
Post actions
I have to say from the outset that I am not a fan of the frame you have chosen, but your photo is nice...
Post actions
Post actions
Picture 10 border 1 So you get a four.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
