I Loved your picture alot and I also like using the same effect with some of my photos. Not everybody likes doing or seeing this kind of funkieness. I'm glad you did it though. Wonderful!!
This looks over processed or over exposed or something over done. It is difficult to look at and see clearly. Done another way, it might be a striking shot because it seems to be and interesting subject and setting.
This doesn't really say "nostalgic" to me, but I love the picture so much I'm not even taking that into consideration with my voting this time. I'm not exactly sure what it is, maybe the pinkish tones or the stark white bottom, or maybe it's just the look in the beast's eye that captures my attention. Whatever it is, I think this is a great shot. Is that a second buffalo lying down on the left there? I think it'd be better without him but that's ok. Still one of my favorites.
if you were trying to make it look like an old time photo...it worked...otherwise too blown out imo. nice subject though - good interpretation of the category...and the big fellow is framed in the shot well. too bright for me...but something tells me you put a little more than average effort into this...6 for effort.
Nice attempt at making this photo look old, but it still looks way too overexposed. I would have tried for darker than usual rather than lighter than usual with this subject.