8 - Nice. Toning works well. Perhaps a variation in the oof arm/'giver' to 'show it' a fraction more may have given this a little extra, but not sure - does work well as is in my opinion. Nice and simple. Perhaps the few slight distractions removed: bottom left and right, but minor.
Such potential here. But, IMO, there is too much space diluting the effect. The flowers are excellent specimens. The tone treatment is very nice. All outstanding but it needs cropping or recomposing. It has the potential to be very good.
the shot is nice and I like the idea, but the arm takes a while to figure out, perhaps I am slow...if you had the face of the person blurred out as well??? not sure, I like it though