Author Thread
Post actions
thanks to all the photographers and the sensor-dust-cleaner... i hope this can be added to besic editing rules...
Post actions
i wanted to add this to my favs cause in my mind this is still a ribbon picture-so beautiful!!
Post actions
I think it's way to hard to DQ someone because of some dust that has been deleted. Dust happens!
Post actions
I've used alien skin plug-in to remove dust from image... i think is valid...Message edited by author 2006-06-30 05:39:37.
Post actions
Outstanding image!! Sorry about your DQ.....there will be more ribbons in your near future, of that I am sure!!
Post actions
Congratulations on your Ribbon with this beautiful image! Fantastic work!
Post actions
Love the lighting, congrats on the well won ribbon.
Post actions
I hope i'll not disqualified. I've used an alien skin plug-in to remove dust from entire image.
Post actions
Wonderful shot! Congratulations on being in third place, it is a great shot although it will probably be disqualified because you cloned out the sensor spot. I have said it in a discussion before and I'll say it again here: It should be allowed to clean sensor spots in basic editing.
Post actions
Lovely picture. Very atmospheric. Well done.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Very cool! Congratulations.
Post actions
You ribboned! great shot...this was one of the standouts in this challenge
Post actions
Congrats with your first ribbon! Way to go!
Post actions
Congratulations on your first ribbon! Great shot!
Post actions
excellent photo ... congratz
Post actions
Nice shot - congratulations on your 3rd place ribbon. Beautiful blues.
Post actions
Hey congratulations, I really like this one, it looks like you should name all your entries Moonlight... they score really high!! ;)
Post actions
Very nice shot. My favorite of the three ribbon winners. Unfortunately, you are not allowed to clone out sensor dust, though! Too bad. Still a great shot.
Post actions
I sure like this one. Very nice colors and balanced composition. Congratulations! I hope it sticks!
Post actions
Awww man - great image, congrats on the ribbon, too bad about the dust :(
Post actions
Congrats on the ribbon, too bad it will be disqualified if what you are saying about the dust spot is true :(
Post actions
Spero non mi bastonino per un commento in italiano :)
Post actions
You should have left the dust spot Gipo. Since there is no spot editing allowed under the basic editing rules the photo will probably be disqualified. It's a shame too because you made a wonderful image. In fact, I'm finding lots of really good stuff in your portfolio. No doubt you will have more ribbons very soon. Good luck!
Post actions
Too bad... I really liked this one. For future reference, stay away from any tools that touch the image when in basic editing.
Post actions
Hmmm... I'm afraid your cloning will be grounds for a DQ :(
Post actions
Wooooooooow! It's my first ribbon... I'm very happy! Thanx to all!
Post actions
congratulations on the well deserved ribbon
Post actions
Well done on your first ribbon!
Post actions
Beautiful! Congrats on your first ribbon! :)
Post actions
I am so glad this won a ribbon. It blew me away the minute I saw it! Congratulations! This is BEAUTIFUL!!!
Post actions
Congrats on your first ever ribbon!
Post actions
Love the shapes in the background of those big rocks. Don't tell the others but this was my pick for the Blue. Congrats on your well deserved Yellow.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I'd have loved to see the moon captured in the photo.
Post actions
Fantastic. Looks almost fake.
Post actions
wow...amazing colour in the green...that looks like an eye just at the bottom of the light path...hope you do really well with this...
Post actions
Very.Cool.
Post actions
very surreal image, and i like the fact that i can see the rocks under the surface of the water towards the foreground. 8.
Post actions
Wow. One of the best of the challenge. Remarkable lighting on the foreground rocks. Good luck!
Post actions
Absolutely wonderful colors. There is a rock in the moon's reflection that almost looks like an eye. One of my top picks for this challenge.
Post actions
Almost perfect. My eye keeps jumping from the left to right backgraund rocks. Maybe a more vertical shot using only the left side of the background would have been better.
Post actions
Composition: 5 - Technical: 7 - Creativity: 6 - Appeal: 7 - Challenge: 6 - Overall Calculated Average Score: 6
Post actions
Very interesting image. The horizon is pretty much undetectable. I assume there were some lights behind you since all of the close features are lit. Nice choice for location. Giving it a bump up.
Post actions
Almost looks like it is from another planet! I really like this. Gave it a 9.
Post actions
This is simply beautiful.
Post actions
I love the blue hues in this and the clarity of the water, the focus seems a tad off, but overall very nice.
Post actions
Ok now my favorite pic love the scene and color and lighting on the water
Post actions
Lovely shot. It feels like a fantasy setting ... like something wonderful is about to happen. Superb reflections. Nice hint of moonlight from above. Neat that I can see the rocks below the water's surface. Well done.
Post actions
Fabulous shot. The sharp rocks against the calm water make for an incredible image. It's amazing how clear the water is as well. This shot is very cool. My only "criticism" is the greenish color cast that the rocks seem to have.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
... moonscape! It would be cool to see the moon, but I have the feeling it is probably too bright? Nice shot.
Post actions
Photo makes me want to know more about the place..and go there. Great job.
Post actions
Post actions
the white balance on the foreground rocks appears to be different from the rest of the photo - was there a different light source? Nice photo, and I like the border on this
Post actions
i note it's your title, and therefore should be the principal subject, but i think your overall composition has suffered a bit from the reflection of the moon... i would really have been tempted to crop out the reflection and (flash lit?) rocks in the bottom third and have more emphasis on the rocks and the lovely lush blues in the background, both of which you have captured very well in a fairytaleesque kind of way. my favourite aspect is that there is no horizon - it's so nice... 6.
Post actions
WHOA!!!! Post card quality and then some!!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Has an eerie quality to it.
Post actions
Simply beautiful. Shame this was basic editing, I would've taken out the buoey (spelling?)
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Meets Challenge:2
Post actions
Wow.
Post actions
An amazing capture of light. So calm. so peaceful.
Post actions
"Breathtaking" night image here.....
Post actions
deserves a high rate well done for a beautiful picture
Post actions
Excellent work... I love this :) 2... no, I mean 9 :)
Post actions
moonscape. Very good photo.
Post actions
For a microscopical burn on the water I rate this beautiful image only 9.
Post actions
Post actions
The blues and greens are beautiful!
Post actions
Post actions
Best I've seen so far. Fantastic composition and great lighting!
Post actions
I like the contrast of colors, but I would have liked to have seen the moon in the sky.
Post actions
Looks like this could be in a fairytale, beautiful shot. The reflection of the moon has really nice colors in it. Great job!
Post actions
Oh WOW! This is breathtaking!!! What a striking composition! Amazing too how you can see the rocks under that crystal clear water. Fantastic photo!
Post actions
It's a great shot. Has had me looking at it for ages.
Post actions
This is pretty cool, however, the bright stones at the bottom are a bit of an attention stealer, if this were an advanced editing challenge I would have darkened them to be in theme with the rocks in the backround but I still really like it as it is, don´t get me wrong. 7 from me.
Post actions
Nice exposure, but the composition leaves a little to be desired.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
