Nice choice! I think it would be more believeable if the pier lower left was cropped out, and the only thing in the photo, was the busted up end of the pier and the deserted boat! wow, what an impact that makes when i crop up and take out the red colored boards! nice job just the same. very nice choice for this challenge.
great composition and overall quite interesting. it does look over sharpened or something, or maybe its just from compression(the lines on the boat being jagged.)
You know, you can leave the image untitled, or just put a '.' for the title. Less distracting than sdfgsdf...
Nice shot, a tad too dark perhaps, but at least no blown highlights in the sky.