CTCP2 Gunnsi
First impression: Much better image. More quality, good focus, better viewing angle and without that noise you added the last time.
What can you do better? I would have liked to see Winnie's face. You also should have told about in wich challenge the original was. Usually children toys do not score high, but a retake from a toy challenge is another thing.
Hey, you improved! I like the black background a lot better, and the angle works well. I like the way you can see a bit of pooh's face in the first one, though. Cute picture!
Greetings from your own critique club. Sorry, I was off the hook for a while.
First Impression Very Nice shot. Much better than the original one. Good improvement and that was the idea of the challenge.
Composition: Better Composition than the original. I would like to see more of Pooh.
Subject: Subject may not be of interest to many voters IMO. That may be one reason for low score. But this challenge had different purpose. You are at disadvantage as voters don't really recall the original to compare the improvement.
Technical (Colour and light): Very nice. Really like the Black BG.
Improvement: Different agnle to include more of Pooh.
Summary: Over all lots of improvement compare to take I.