Camera Work/Technical: Great focus and very interesting death of field. The quality of this exposure is far better than the original submission. Your choice of ISO 100 produced a much better result.
Lighting: Again, much better than the original. I do think I would prefer the bottle behind the flaming glass to give the label a little light boost.
Composition/Content: While the composition is very similar, the details of the content are much more evident in this capture, thus producing a better image.
My Opinion: I think that this one is better than the voters credited you for. Your lighting change alone is worth more than the small score change they gave you.