Sorry to see that this didn't rank higher. It is a beautiful shot. Perhaps the bottom half is a bit too heavy. You can't really crop from it without losing the proportion though because you wouldn't want to crop any from the sides. Nice use of negative space. I love the colors.
Very nice silhouette and sunset! IMO, and that's just my opinion, a less prominent border would enhance the picture; it's such a beautiful picture, it doesn't need such a heavy border. ~9
It's a lovely scene but the border is a bit overkill. Perhaps a little too much space filled for me and the saturation is spilling over a bit, creating a bit of noise. Great composition.
What is REALLY cool about this image is that the negative space is opposite of what you would expect, with the trees, shrubs, and valley the negative space and the Sun as the subject. Great job!! 8.