Author Thread
Post actions
Your colors and texture in this image are superb. I like how you've taken a very simple subject and presented it in a clear and uncluttered manner... I need to work on that myself.
Post actions
Steely failure. Congratulations on your top 20 finish, Rob.
Post actions
Hey, is that yours? It was one of my favorites. I gave it a ten.
Post actions
Wait a minute, this is not a landscape! Like the composition and the contrasting colours and shapes.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Hard to break a nife like this.
Post actions
Post actions
Technically, this is very good. I like your interpretation of the challenge.
Post actions
Post actions
I don't think a knife could break that way in that position, but your photo looks nice.
Post actions
Great composition and near-flawless lighting. I do find the bright light at the bottom left of the squash-thingy a little distracting. This one fits into the challenge nicely. Nice image overall.
Post actions
I'd prefer to see the knife broken at the handle which is what would really happen, surely?!! A bit too contrived for me
Post actions
Failure of the knife, fits the challenge well...8
Post actions
thats a clean cut. very interesting.
Post actions
Cool but not very convincing, this just feels a bit sterile like it is, would have been much cooler if there was a hand holding the handle with some motion blur or whatever, not having this set up like it is. Nice job on the lighting and good idea, gave it a 7.
Post actions
Very clever (assuming it's an illusion rather than the obvious).
Post actions
good subject, comp and crop, lighting could be better (light below cardboard distracts)
Post actions
great lighting in this shot...well done
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
