I like this one very much. The items and colors work well. I wish the wine glasses had been arranged differently though as the shadow is pretty harsh. 8
This meets the challenge – it’s inanimate and arranged. V. classic. V. good. Could have left the whole wine glass in on the right. I'd back the clour saturation down, but maybe that's just me... 8
classic arrangement, crop could be less tight at right, wine is too dark (make it thinner with water or take red juice), cheese needs light from the right, pear could be more visible. A candle would have been great. - 7 for your effort
This is my favorite of the challenge... and one of the relatively few that actually seem to be a still life in the traditional sense. I like the mood you created with the lighting, and the overall colors involved. If I had a criticism to offer, it would be the shadown on the cheese from the wine glass, but I still like it well enough to give it a 10. Nice work!