Personally I liked everything about this shot, including the beds others didnt care for. Most children practice their instruments in their bedroom so I found the setting perfect.
I could just see a child practicing away while looking out the window dreaming of his or her recital. This photo told more of a story than any other in the challenge. Personally I think it should have been top 15 easy. :)
Without the title and challenge, this is a good photo on its own, though the window is a bit too bright. The tones are overall very nicely done and the crop is good. I don't like the bed in the shot, as it takes away from the "recital."
On the one hand, between the titleand the look of the piece, I don\'t really feel like this is \"inside looking out\" but rather \"inside looking inside\", with the \"out\" merely a backdrop. On the other hand, it\'s a very pretty backdrop and the scene is well-composed, the light sufficient to show most details inside in spite of the outside\'s glare.
I'll bet this picture is a lot more interesting than I'm seeing, but it is too dark to make out the objects of the interior. I think you need more light in the room or a little flash to bring it out.
IT READS DARK.PERHAPS SOME EASIER TO SEE MUSIC ON THE STAND.THE CANE IS NICE, BUT HARD TO SEE. NOT SURE ABOTU THE BEDS, ESPECIALLY THE ONE ON THE RIGHT.
more light in the foreground or more detail would have helped this but the almost watercolor effect of the tree outside the window is wonderful
title isn't clear to me