Author Thread
Post actions
I think this is absolutely gorgeous. I finally figured out how to set up my favorite photographers so I can look at all of your photos.
Post actions
Wonderful image. I would like to try something like this. The lighting is surperb!
Post actions
So close, yet so far. Great framing job. You'll get that ribbon yet.
Post actions
You ended up pretty close, so just keep up the good work and your day will come. Good job
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I love it. The lighting, the mood and the view... Well done, my highest rated photo. 9 I bet this is a ribbon winner...
Post actions
Excellent! Very nice vignetting(sorry spelling). Perfect lighting 9 I would love to see it in color
Post actions
i really like this. i live at the beach, so i can see this on the wall of any number of houses! :) great framing, the tree branch really enhances the shot. the sky is cool and i like the reflection on the water. nice work!
Post actions
If the reflection wasn't overexposed, this would be a 9 or 10. I like the dark silhouettes, but should have exposed the water correctly. 7
Post actions
Quite an interesting shot, though I would have loved to have seen it in color. My guess is that you did b&w because the color version was not quite spectacular though. I like the composition as well as the concept. Makes me think of one of those caves that eventually fills up with water at high tide.
Post actions
This would have been a great shot for contrasts
Post actions
This is one of my favorites from this challenge - utterly gorgeous, from the silhouette framing to the water itself. A lot of glare here, but it only takes out details at its brightest, and is itself a focus by the way the picture is set - very nice. Love being able to see the wavelets breaking near the bottom of the frame.
Post actions
Not only you perfectly fit the theme but the picture is absolutely wonderful. I would like to see a color version.
Post actions
Good job. My personal preference would have been that this one be in color, but I do like the photo.
Post actions
Like the composition and the color choices. What method did you use to get these tones? Good use of textures between the soft clouds, the active ocean and the dead/inert limb and cave.
Post actions
I like the composition though the bright reflection on the water seems a bit too birght.
Post actions
I love the silhouette, and the lighting on the clouds. The irregularity of the framing of the opening helps the bw establish tension, I think.
Post actions
great view and the sunlight angle is very appealing as well
Post actions
Post actions
Great photo! You'll do well in this competition. I wish I lived where you live!
Post actions
Great shot. Good job on the lighting and good choice going B&W. The clouds, the light shining on the water and the craggy branch hanging down give this lots of drama. 10
Post actions
Beautiful image and interpretation. Good luck in the challenge!
Post actions
Excellent framing. the sky and sea seem blown ou. Did you try darkening the image? Good luck. Jacko. 8
Post actions
I think a little less contrast with some detail in the dar areas would really make this a teriffic photo. nice shot!!
Post actions
Nice choice to use B&W. Simply beautiful. 10
Post actions
Very nice and interresting natural border and the photo looks very good in B&W.
Post actions
this is washed out for me, and the foreground doesn't seem focused.
Post actions
Beautiful picture!! I think this is the best picture I've seen in this challenge...second only to mine, of course! :) 10
Post actions
Beautiful shot. Meets the challenge. Composition good. Good luck.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
