Very nice shot. I would have cropped it a tiny bit more at the botton, that part of the photograph takes my attention away from the rest and that is truly a shame. Either it is the very bright green or that it is not focused = a tiny bit more cropping would have helped imo, but lovely colours and composition. Excellent to have that tree on the left.
Color/exposure/contrast: 2/2 perfect. i like the color palette Focus/sharpness/DOF: 1.5/2 good sharpness, and dof but focus should e on the lower deers not the back ones Idea/creativity: 2/2 2 just for the fact that is mighty hard to get near a herd of so many deers Theme: 1/2 should use something else that meant the same as a title, birds is a little bit unappropriate, and the second one does not sound so melodic Framing/appeal: 2/2 i like it! TOTAL:8.5