Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting concept that if it were sharper, would be a ribbon contender.
Post actions
you have to compete with some top notch images, and this is just too plain
Post actions
Nicely done. I sort of find myself wishing there was a big, puffy, cumulous cloud in the middle of the window frame, but it's a great shot, nonetheless. 7
Post actions
Lovely idea, should have cloned out the strings attached to the top, otherwise nicely done, beautiful blue
Post actions
Nice shot but still, something is missing for me to be really blown away by it, like a bird flying overhead in the window or something... 6 from me.
Post actions
INCOMING!
Post actions
Creative shot... wonder how many shots it took... wait... I think I see fishing line! hehee... good colors and contrast, good luck!
Post actions
Post actions
great concept except for the string attached at the top.
Post actions
Different! But rather plain, overall, as far as something to look at. Maybe if there had been clouds ONLY in the window or if you'd included more of the surrounding view but still keeping the perspective of the window hanging in space.
Post actions
hahaha good idea .. though I find the tree a little distracting
Post actions
ooops you could still see the string holding up the frame. great idea though ;)
Post actions
Interesting idea, but the tree on the right spoils the effect. More clouds and a darker sky would have made it more effective.
Post actions
Post actions
great idea but it seems to lack something
Post actions
A good idea but the sky is not interesting enough imo.
Post actions
Very cool and creative idea. You can barely see the strings at the top.
Post actions
been done too many times, still i do like it, shame about the trees
Post actions
this is a great idea but the line holding up the window didn't get edited out??
Post actions
I really love the idea, but I think adding a little spark into the photo, it would be even better. The branches at the bottom, top and right don't really add anything to the photo.
Post actions
I like it, but not sure about the branches
Post actions
i like the idea, the only thing is for the title being 'clouded window" there sure is not alot of clouds :)
Post actions
I see your strings! I like the floating window though
Post actions
Very unique...congrats on your creativity.
Post actions
Good idea - I think I would have cloned out the strings though. I dont think they would have counted as a major element - just a minor distraction here. You feel compelled to look for them and unfortunately you can find them.
Post actions
Great concept, but you can see the strings!!
Post actions
Because there are clouds outside the window frame, it seems more a picture of a window than of a window framing something. I am also distracted by the trees, particularly along the bottom edge where they could (and should) have been very easily cropped out.
Post actions
The Idea is nice, but there's nothing interesting framed...
Post actions
Very clever idea. I would have liked it even more if the window frame was white...
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
