This is a wonderful shot, I'm really a fan of the selective desat and the rich tones of the color in the flowers. The one thing I don't like is the flower thats hanging out over the windwo from the basket on the lower right.
You did a very nice job selectively desaturating this picture. I like the rustic feeling of it. I know you as I wish that the tag was not hanging down from the basket in the middle of the picture but that was probably out of your control.
It was a good decision to use selective desaturation for this photograph. The flowers might not have come out well enough otherwise. You might have desaturated the plants in the upper part of the window as well though, since they're not something you'd want attention to be drawn on.
great use of desat. it would be nice to see is slightly sharpper, i'm assuming it was the downsize that caused the little bit of fuzzyess that bothers me just a tad, but i'll be understanding.
(always remember to sharpen a tad after the downsize for the web. [if detail is lost in compairson to the big]) still a great shot.
Good use of desat. I like the old condition of the wood. The only distraction is the price tag in the middle of the window (which you had no control over).
I really like the use of selective desaturation here as it serves to answer the challenge theme well, and emphasizes the textures in the shot.... I vote 7
I love that. Sometimes selective saturation is kind of "odd" for me but I find this lovely. I'd probably like the entire shot done in color too, or maybe even the entire thing in sepia. The composition is lovely. Great old window.