I especially like the colors in this one - it's a bit grainy and/or blurry here and there. I'm not sure how well that could be controlled with the lighting involved, but it does detract from the power of the photo. I like the effect of heavy lines of the grill against the much softer, paler cup's outline, and the reflections in the cup are a nice touch as well.
Well, this is a really cool picture. I like the colors and the lighting really works. Unfortunatly for this challenge the main focus was right angles, and the main focus here is the mug. Would have been great for the temperature challenge. Great photo despite it!
A tiny bit of noise. Composition is great. Maybe if the mug was a different colors the shadows on it would come out more. It won't have the glow that it has, but it would give the picture an interest contrast.
Composition = 10
Challenge = 1
no right angles with perspective shift and streighth of pic is not a right angle
Technical = 6
would like more focus
Creativity = 10
X2 Wow factor =10
47/6=7.8