Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
uninspiring & lifeless. It meets the challenge but is not very well executed low-key photography. 3
Post actions
This is a bit too underexposed.
Post actions
The seed of a good idea. How about adding an additional element of a sliced apple, with bright white flesh. Less central composition would be better.
Post actions
I think this image would be stronger if it were sharper and had less noise.
Post actions
Yours is a nice idea but may have been implemented better. The sharpness of this image is not crisp and that is very important in minimalist compositions such as this. Centering the apple on one of the rule of thirds intersection points may have made the image more interesting to the viewer's eye. More sidelighting to add greater tonality to the image is worth a try.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting idea...I think the soft focus takes something away IMO.
Post actions
Post actions
blurry for my tastes but I like the use of shadow.
Post actions
Don't care for the soft feel
Post actions
feels just a little too dark...
Post actions
Would have been awesome if the apple were more in focus
Post actions
Too low key with too much dead space for me. Focus also seems to be a bit off.
Post actions
it just looks like a blurry apple in the dark...sorry
Post actions
I'd like this if it were tack sharp, and way to the left of the frame.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
