Very creative concept. A little hot (overexposed) - this would have scored higher if it wasn't. 5 from me for creativity, could have been an 8. Hopefully I'm an anomaly. ;^) Good luck in the challenge.
I should have kept the score a secret? I'm the only one not marked helpful. :(
great shot! totally unique and individual, definitly, nothing I have ever seen before or would have ever thought of. It kind of reminds me of a picture on a poster in a class room with cute drawings surroundong it on the wall. The lighting washes out a little bit of the erasers at the bottom of the pencils on front but other than that I love it. I don't really know how you could fix it though because I am not that great...yet. *smile*
Very cute idea, althought the blown out spot on the bottom middle (where the erasers are) is kind of a nit...and also that you almost cut off part of the ribbon on the left side. But, being really nit picky there. Great pic and great idea!
This is a really creative idea for a composition! The color is nice, but the flash washout on the pencils' erasers is a little bit of a distraction. Other than that this is a great shot! Nice texture - good focus and cropping!
How fun! and with the blue ribbon.....very clever! I have to say! I really wish you didn't have the harsh reflections on the apple, they seem distrating to me, but I still love the concept! So I am bumping you up to 8
Outstanding photo. Two things bother me though: at the front 2 pencils the bottom is blown out and the crop on the left side is a bit tight(you cut the tip of the ribbon). But still... 9.Good luck!
clever set up - rather pretty, my preference would have been to have less crop on the sides allowing some space past the ribbon ends and the lighting seems a wee bit much - blown out on pencil tips and especially front of erasers - a good studio idea though and certainly meets the challenge - good job :)
Very creative concept. A little hot (overexposed) - this would have scored higher if it wasn't. 5 from me for creativity, could have been an 8. Hopefully I'm an anomaly. ;^) Good luck in the challenge.
Very interesting and clever still life. Highlights a tiny bit blown out at bottom of pencils and reflections a bit much on the apple, but still a good job.