This was your entry for the 'Pick Two' challenge. Definitely meets the challenge, there are indeed feathers and high heeled shoes :-) Congrats on the top 20 for this lovely photo. This is a tough one to critique, I frankly see nothing 'wrong' with the photo at all. I could maybe suggest things to do different, but they would only be that, different, and not at all necessarily 'improvement' :-) But I shall try and give you some of my thoughts.
I really like the low contrast approach here. The image is very pleasing to look at, and has a very sensuous feel to it. It lends itself well to the processing you have done, IMO. The positioning of the legs is great. That and the slight arch in the back I feel contribute a lot to the 'feel' of the photo. It might be nice to see a little bit more of the feet, although I wouldn't change the positioning of the legs/feet at all, and I don't know if changing the position of the shoes and boa might alter the composition adversely or not. The dark inner side of the heel of the shoe kind of keeps pulling my eye to it. One of your commenters mentioned perhaps lying one shoe on the side, maybe this could prevent that darkness from being as prominent? One of your comments mentions the slight lack of detail in feathers and shoes, but I'd guess that in the full size/res photo, it probably looks great.
This is just a really fine photo. The low contrast treatment quickly grabs your attention, and then the soft sensuous feel of the image demands the viewer lingers a while to fully enjoy the presentation. Very nicely done, congrats :-)
If you have any questions or comments or anything, please feel free to contact me.
This is such a great photo! Great score and strong finish. I would not have been at all surprised to see this with a ribbon. congratulations on such cool work.
Nice pose, lines, composition. Low-contrast image has a nice soft feel, but I think that you have taken it just a little too far - slightly more contrast and more image detail would be better.
I am inclined to guess that this is someone I know. I will not call you but I believe you are already in my faves list ;) Good luck. Bumping up this beautiful and sensual BW rendition.
I really like the set up of this photo but there is not much contrast. Maybe darker shoes would have helped and I would have liked to see the feet up in the air a bit with pointed toes. Just my thought.
I think I'd like maybe one of the shoes laying over on the side, so they aren't just lined up like little soldiers. Or, maybe if she were wearing the shoes. The overall paleness works. Nice curve of the woman's back.